Here’s something that might surprise you: 73% of Medicare beneficiaries miss their chance to switch plans each year simply because they don’t know when they can make changes.
That’s a staggering number when you consider how much money and coverage flexibility is at stake.
I’m Adam, and I’ve been helping folks navigate Medicare for over 25 years. Trust me, I’ve seen too many people stuck with plans that don’t fit their needs anymore just because they missed their enrollment window.
The truth is, Medicare Advantage enrollment isn’t as complicated as the government makes it sound. But you’ve got to know the key dates, or you’ll be waiting another whole year to make changes.
Let’s break down exactly when you can enroll, disenroll, and switch your Medicare Advantage plan so you never miss an opportunity again.
Medicare Advantage Annual Open Enrollment Period
The big kahuna of enrollment periods runs from October 15th through December 7th every single year. This is your main window to make changes to your Medicare Advantage plan.
During these 54 days, you’ve got more flexibility than a yoga instructor. You can switch from one Medicare Advantage plan to another, drop your MA plan and go back to Original Medicare, or even add a prescription drug plan if you’re making that jump.
Key Dates and Deadlines
Mark your calendar right now. October 15th is when the gates open, and December 7th is when they slam shut.
But here’s where it gets interesting – your new coverage doesn’t start until January 1st of the following year. So if you enroll on October 20th, you’re still stuck with your current plan through December 31st.
I’ve had clients think they could switch in November and have it take effect immediately. Nope, doesn’t work that way.
The insurance companies have to send you your new membership cards and materials by December 31st. If you don’t get them by then, something went wrong and you need to call immediately.
What You Can Do During Open Enrollment
This period is like Black Friday for Medicare – everything’s available.
You can switch from any Medicare Advantage plan to any other Medicare Advantage plan in your area. No questions asked, no medical underwriting.
Want to ditch your Medicare Advantage plan altogether? You can switch back to Original Medicare Part A and B. Just remember, you’ll probably want to add a Part D prescription drug plan too.
You can also switch from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan during this time.
One thing you can’t do? Switch Medigap policies without answering health questions. That ship usually sails after your first year on Medicare.
Medicare Advantage Disenrollment Period
Here’s a period that flies under most people’s radar, but it’s gold if you need it.
From January 1st through March 31st, you get one more bite at the apple. But there’s a catch – you can only use this period to drop your Medicare Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare.
You cannot switch from one Medicare Advantage plan to another during this period. It’s exit only, not transfer.
Why would you want to do this? Maybe your new plan isn’t working out like you hoped. Perhaps your doctors aren’t in the network like you thought, or the drug coverage is terrible.
I had a client last year who realized in February that her new Medicare Advantage plan didn’t cover her preferred cancer center. She was able to drop the plan and go back to Original Medicare, which gave her the flexibility to see any doctor who accepts Medicare.
If you drop your Medicare Advantage plan during this period, you can also add a standalone Part D prescription drug plan. In fact, you should, because Original Medicare doesn’t include prescription coverage.
The coverage change takes effect the first day of the month after your plan receives your disenrollment request.
Special Enrollment Periods for Medicare Advantage
Life doesn’t wait for October 15th, and neither should you when certain situations come up.
Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs) are like get-out-of-jail-free cards. They let you make changes to your Medicare coverage outside of the normal enrollment windows.
But you can’t just wake up one day and decide you want a SEP. You need what Medicare calls a “qualifying life event.”
Qualifying Life Events
Moving to a new area is probably the most common trigger. If you relocate outside your current plan’s service area, you get a SEP.
I’ve helped plenty of snowbirds who realized their Michigan Medicare Advantage plan doesn’t work in Florida. Good news – you get to switch.
Losing other creditable coverage also qualifies. Maybe you’re still working at 67 and your employer health insurance gets cancelled. That triggers a SEP.
Changes in your Medicaid or Extra Help status can open enrollment windows too.
Getting married or divorced? That’s a qualifying event.
If your plan gets cancelled or significantly changes its benefits, you automatically get a SEP.
Here’s something most people don’t know: if you’re in a nursing home or other long-term care facility, you get a permanent SEP. You can change plans any month of the year.
The tricky part is timing. Most SEPs only last 63 days from the qualifying event. Miss that window and you’re back to waiting for October.
How to Prepare for Medicare Advantage Enrollment
Don’t wait until October 14th to start thinking about your Medicare Advantage plan. That’s like cramming for a final exam the night before.
Preparation is everything in this game.
Reviewing Your Current Plan
Start by digging into your current plan’s performance. How did it treat you this year?
Look at your Summary of Benefits. Did your copays go up? Are your doctors still in-network? What about your prescription drugs – are they still covered?
I tell my clients to keep a simple notebook throughout the year. Write down every time you have an issue with your plan. Trust me, come October, you’ll forget about that time in March when your plan refused to cover your MRI.
Check your plan’s star rating too. Medicare rates plans from 1 to 5 stars based on quality and performance. If your plan dropped from 4 stars to 2 stars, that’s a red flag.
Don’t forget to look at next year’s changes. Every September, your plan has to send you an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC). This document tells you exactly what’s changing for the following year.
Sometimes the changes are minor – maybe your primary care copay goes from $15 to $20. Other times, they’re massive – like dropping coverage for your expensive diabetes medication.
Comparing New Plan Options
This is where the rubber meets the road.
Start with your must-haves. What doctors do you absolutely need to keep seeing? What prescriptions can’t you live without?
Use Medicare’s Plan Finder tool at medicare.gov. It’s clunky and not the prettiest interface, but it’s accurate and official.
Don’t get dazzled by all the extra benefits. Yeah, it’s nice that a plan covers gym memberships and dental cleanings. But if it doesn’t cover your heart medication, those perks don’t matter.
Look at the plan’s provider network carefully. Just because a doctor accepts Medicare doesn’t mean they’re in your Medicare Advantage plan’s network.
Consider your budget for the whole year, not just the monthly premium. A $0 premium plan might cost you $3,000 more in copays and deductibles than a $50/month plan.
Important Considerations Before Making Changes
Hold your horses before you jump to a new plan just because it looks shiny.
First thing to consider: are you happy with your current plan? I know that sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many people switch plans just because they can.
If your current plan is working well, your doctors are happy with it, and your costs are reasonable, maybe don’t fix what ain’t broken.
But if you’re switching, think about timing. Remember, any change you make takes effect January 1st. So if you’ve got a surgery scheduled for December, your current plan will handle it.
Consider your health trajectory too. Are you getting sicker or healthier? If you’re dealing with new chronic conditions, you might need a plan with better specialist networks.
Don’t forget about prescription drug coverage. This trips up more people than anything else. Your new plan might cover your blood pressure medication but not your diabetes drugs.
Geography matters more than you think. Some plans have great networks in your county but terrible networks in the next county over. If you travel or visit family regularly, check the networks where you go.
And here’s something that’ll make your head spin: plans can change their networks mid-year. It doesn’t happen often, but it happens. Your doctor could be in-network in January and out-of-network in July.
Common Enrollment Mistakes to Avoid
I’ve seen every mistake in the book, and some of them are doozies.
The biggest mistake? Procrastinating. Don’t wait until December 6th to start shopping. You’ll make rushed decisions and probably pick the wrong plan.
Another whopper: choosing based on premium alone. I had a client who picked a $0 premium plan and ended up paying $4,000 more in out-of-pocket costs than her old plan would have cost.
Don’t assume your doctors are in-network just because they accept Medicare. Call their offices and ask specifically if they accept your new plan. Better yet, get it in writing.
Here’s a mistake that makes my teeth hurt: not checking prescription drug coverage. Some folks assume all Medicare plans cover all drugs. They don’t. Not even close.
Failing to consider out-of-area coverage is another big one. If you spend winters in Arizona but live in Ohio, make sure your plan works in both places.
Don’t get seduced by marketing materials. That glossy brochure makes every plan look amazing. Dig into the actual benefits and costs.
Ignoring star ratings is like buying a car without checking its safety rating. Plans with higher star ratings generally provide better service and outcomes.
And please, for the love of all that’s holy, don’t believe everything you see on TV commercials. Those “Medicare benefits you deserve” ads are usually selling Medicare Advantage plans, and they make promises that individual plans might not keep.
Leave a Reply